(*
* Single-conclusion proofs; this is an alternate representation
* where each inference has only a single conclusion. These have
- * worse compositionality properties than ND's, but are easier to
- * emit as LaTeX code.
+ * worse compositionality properties than ND's (they don't form a
+ * category), but are easier to emit as LaTeX code.
*)
Inductive SCND : Tree ??Judgment -> Tree ??Judgment -> Type :=
- | scnd_comp : forall ht ct c , SCND ht ct -> Rule ct [c] -> SCND ht [c]
| scnd_weak : forall c , SCND c []
- | scnd_leaf : forall ht c , SCND ht [c] -> SCND ht [c]
+ | scnd_comp : forall ht ct c , SCND ht ct -> Rule ct [c] -> SCND ht [c]
| scnd_branch : forall ht c1 c2, SCND ht c1 -> SCND ht c2 -> SCND ht (c1,,c2)
.
Hint Constructors SCND.
inversion k; subst; inversion X0; subst; auto.
destruct c.
destruct o.
- apply scnd_leaf. eapply scnd_comp. apply k. apply r.
+ eapply scnd_comp. apply k. apply r.
apply scnd_weak.
set (all_rules_one_conclusion _ _ _ r) as bogus.
inversion bogus.
refine ((fix closedFromPnodes h c (pn2:SCND h c)(cnd:ClosedND h) {struct pn2} :=
(match pn2 in SCND H C return H=h -> C=c -> _ with
| scnd_weak c => let case_weak := tt in _
- | scnd_leaf ht z pn' => let case_leaf := tt in let qq := closedFromPnodes _ _ pn' in _
| scnd_comp ht ct c pn' rule => let case_comp := tt in let qq := closedFromPnodes _ _ pn' in _
| scnd_branch ht c1 c2 pn' pn'' => let case_branch := tt in
let q1 := closedFromPnodes _ _ pn' in
end (refl_equal _) (refl_equal _))) h c pn2 cnd).
- destruct case_comp.
- intros.
- clear pn2.
- apply (cnd_rule ct).
- apply qq.
- subst.
- apply cnd0.
- apply rule.
-
destruct case_weak.
intros; subst.
apply cnd_weak.
- destruct case_leaf.
+ destruct case_comp.
intros.
+ clear pn2.
+ apply (cnd_rule ct).
apply qq.
subst.
apply cnd0.
+ apply rule.
destruct case_branch.
intros.
| nd_property_rule : forall h c r, P h c r -> @nd_property _ _ P h c (nd_rule r).
Hint Constructors nd_property.
+(* witnesses the fact that every Rule in a particular proof satisfies the given predicate *)
+Inductive cnd_property {Judgment}{Rule}(P:forall h c, @Rule h c -> Prop) : forall {c}, @ClosedND Judgment Rule c -> Prop :=
+| cnd_property_weak : @cnd_property _ _ P _ cnd_weak
+| cnd_property_rule : forall h c r cnd',
+ P h c r ->
+ @cnd_property _ _ P h cnd' ->
+ @cnd_property _ _ P c (cnd_rule _ _ cnd' r)
+| cnd_property_branch :
+ forall c1 c2 cnd1 cnd2,
+ @cnd_property _ _ P c1 cnd1 ->
+ @cnd_property _ _ P c2 cnd2 ->
+ @cnd_property _ _ P _ (cnd_branch _ _ cnd1 cnd2).
+
+Inductive scnd_property {Judgment}{Rule}(P:forall h c, @Rule h c -> Prop) : forall {h c}, @SCND Judgment Rule h c -> Prop :=
+| scnd_property_weak : forall c, @scnd_property _ _ P _ _ (scnd_weak c)
+| scnd_property_comp : forall h x c r cnd',
+ P x [c] r ->
+ @scnd_property _ _ P h x cnd' ->
+ @scnd_property _ _ P h _ (scnd_comp _ _ _ cnd' r)
+| scnd_property_branch :
+ forall x c1 c2 cnd1 cnd2,
+ @scnd_property _ _ P x c1 cnd1 ->
+ @scnd_property _ _ P x c2 cnd2 ->
+ @scnd_property _ _ P x _ (scnd_branch _ _ _ cnd1 cnd2).
+
Close Scope pf_scope.
Close Scope nd_scope.