Make mkDFunUnfolding more robust

[ghc-hetmet.git] / compiler / coreSyn / CoreUnfold.lhs

diff --git a/compiler/coreSyn/CoreUnfold.lhs b/compiler/coreSyn/CoreUnfold.lhs
index 0510e90..06a2d72 100644 (file)
--- a/compiler/coreSyn/CoreUnfold.lhs
+++ b/compiler/coreSyn/CoreUnfold.lhs
@@ -1,4 +1,4 @@
-calcU%
+%

 % (c) The University of Glasgow 2006
 % (c) The AQUA Project, Glasgow University, 1994-1998
 %
 % (c) The University of Glasgow 2006
 % (c) The AQUA Project, Glasgow University, 1994-1998
 %

@@ -19,13 +19,14 @@ module CoreUnfold (
        Unfolding, UnfoldingGuidance,   -- Abstract types
 
        noUnfolding, mkImplicitUnfolding, 
        Unfolding, UnfoldingGuidance,   -- Abstract types
 
        noUnfolding, mkImplicitUnfolding, 

-       mkTopUnfolding, mkUnfolding, mkCoreUnfolding,
-       mkInlineRule, mkWwInlineRule,
+        mkUnfolding, mkCoreUnfolding,
+       mkTopUnfolding, mkSimpleUnfolding,
+       mkInlineUnfolding, mkInlinableUnfolding, mkWwInlineRule,

        mkCompulsoryUnfolding, mkDFunUnfolding,
 
        interestingArg, ArgSummary(..),
 
        mkCompulsoryUnfolding, mkDFunUnfolding,
 
        interestingArg, ArgSummary(..),
 

-       couldBeSmallEnoughToInline, 
+       couldBeSmallEnoughToInline, inlineBoringOk,

        certainlyWillInline, smallEnoughToInline,
 
        callSiteInline, CallCtxt(..), 
        certainlyWillInline, smallEnoughToInline,
 
        callSiteInline, CallCtxt(..), 

@@ -40,9 +41,11 @@ import StaticFlags
 import DynFlags
 import CoreSyn
 import PprCore         ()      -- Instances
 import DynFlags
 import CoreSyn
 import PprCore         ()      -- Instances

-import OccurAnal
+import TcType           ( tcSplitDFunTy )
+import OccurAnal        ( occurAnalyseExpr )

 import CoreSubst hiding( substTy )
 import CoreFVs         ( exprFreeVars )
 import CoreSubst hiding( substTy )
 import CoreFVs         ( exprFreeVars )

+import CoreArity       ( manifestArity, exprBotStrictness_maybe )

 import CoreUtils
 import Id
 import DataCon
 import CoreUtils
 import Id
 import DataCon

@@ -51,8 +54,7 @@ import Literal
 import PrimOp
 import IdInfo
 import BasicTypes      ( Arity )
 import PrimOp
 import IdInfo
 import BasicTypes      ( Arity )

-import TcType          ( tcSplitDFunTy )
-import Type 
+import Type

 import Coercion
 import PrelNames
 import VarEnv           ( mkInScopeSet )
 import Coercion
 import PrelNames
 import VarEnv           ( mkInScopeSet )

@@ -61,7 +63,7 @@ import Util
 import FastTypes
 import FastString
 import Outputable
 import FastTypes
 import FastString
 import Outputable

-
+import Data.Maybe

 \end{code}
 
 
 \end{code}
 
 

@@ -72,12 +74,12 @@ import Outputable
 %************************************************************************
 
 \begin{code}
 %************************************************************************
 
 \begin{code}

-mkTopUnfolding :: CoreExpr -> Unfolding
-mkTopUnfolding expr = mkUnfolding True {- Top level -} expr
+mkTopUnfolding :: Bool -> CoreExpr -> Unfolding
+mkTopUnfolding = mkUnfolding InlineRhs True {- Top level -}

 
 mkImplicitUnfolding :: CoreExpr -> Unfolding
 -- For implicit Ids, do a tiny bit of optimising first
 
 mkImplicitUnfolding :: CoreExpr -> Unfolding
 -- For implicit Ids, do a tiny bit of optimising first

-mkImplicitUnfolding expr = mkTopUnfolding (simpleOptExpr expr)
+mkImplicitUnfolding expr = mkTopUnfolding False (simpleOptExpr expr) 

 
 -- Note [Top-level flag on inline rules]
 -- ~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~
 
 -- Note [Top-level flag on inline rules]
 -- ~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~

@@ -85,10 +87,78 @@ mkImplicitUnfolding expr = mkTopUnfolding (simpleOptExpr expr)
 -- top-level flag to True.  It gets set more accurately by the simplifier
 -- Simplify.simplUnfolding.
 
 -- top-level flag to True.  It gets set more accurately by the simplifier
 -- Simplify.simplUnfolding.
 

-mkUnfolding :: Bool -> CoreExpr -> Unfolding
-mkUnfolding top_lvl expr
+mkSimpleUnfolding :: CoreExpr -> Unfolding
+mkSimpleUnfolding = mkUnfolding InlineRhs False False
+
+mkDFunUnfolding :: Type -> [DFunArg CoreExpr] -> Unfolding
+mkDFunUnfolding dfun_ty ops 
+  = DFunUnfolding dfun_nargs data_con ops
+  where
+    (tvs, n_theta, cls, _) = tcSplitDFunTy dfun_ty
+    dfun_nargs = length tvs + n_theta
+    data_con   = classDataCon cls
+
+mkWwInlineRule :: Id -> CoreExpr -> Arity -> Unfolding
+mkWwInlineRule id expr arity
+  = mkCoreUnfolding (InlineWrapper id) True
+                   (simpleOptExpr expr) arity
+                   (UnfWhen unSaturatedOk boringCxtNotOk)
+
+mkCompulsoryUnfolding :: CoreExpr -> Unfolding
+mkCompulsoryUnfolding expr        -- Used for things that absolutely must be unfolded
+  = mkCoreUnfolding InlineCompulsory True
+                    expr 0    -- Arity of unfolding doesn't matter
+                    (UnfWhen unSaturatedOk boringCxtOk)
+
+mkInlineUnfolding :: Maybe Arity -> CoreExpr -> Unfolding
+mkInlineUnfolding mb_arity expr 
+  = mkCoreUnfolding InlineStable
+                   True         -- Note [Top-level flag on inline rules]
+                    expr' arity 
+                   (UnfWhen unsat_ok boring_ok)
+  where
+    expr' = simpleOptExpr expr
+    (unsat_ok, arity) = case mb_arity of
+                          Nothing -> (unSaturatedOk, manifestArity expr')
+                          Just ar -> (needSaturated, ar)
+              
+    boring_ok = inlineBoringOk expr'
+
+mkInlinableUnfolding :: CoreExpr -> Unfolding
+mkInlinableUnfolding expr
+  = mkUnfolding InlineStable True is_bot expr'
+  where
+    expr' = simpleOptExpr expr
+    is_bot = isJust (exprBotStrictness_maybe expr')
+\end{code}
+
+Internal functions
+
+\begin{code}
+mkCoreUnfolding :: UnfoldingSource -> Bool -> CoreExpr
+                -> Arity -> UnfoldingGuidance -> Unfolding
+-- Occurrence-analyses the expression before capturing it
+mkCoreUnfolding src top_lvl expr arity guidance 

   = CoreUnfolding { uf_tmpl      = occurAnalyseExpr expr,
   = CoreUnfolding { uf_tmpl      = occurAnalyseExpr expr,

-                   uf_src        = InlineRhs,
+                   uf_src        = src,
+                   uf_arity      = arity,
+                   uf_is_top     = top_lvl,
+                   uf_is_value   = exprIsHNF        expr,
+                    uf_is_conlike = exprIsConLike    expr,
+                   uf_is_cheap   = exprIsCheap      expr,
+                   uf_expandable = exprIsExpandable expr,
+                   uf_guidance   = guidance }
+
+mkUnfolding :: UnfoldingSource -> Bool -> Bool -> CoreExpr -> Unfolding
+-- Calculates unfolding guidance
+-- Occurrence-analyses the expression before capturing it
+mkUnfolding src top_lvl is_bottoming expr
+  | top_lvl && is_bottoming
+  , not (exprIsTrivial expr)
+  = NoUnfolding    -- See Note [Do not inline top-level bottoming functions]
+  | otherwise
+  = CoreUnfolding { uf_tmpl      = occurAnalyseExpr expr,
+                   uf_src        = src,

                    uf_arity      = arity,
                    uf_is_top     = top_lvl,
                    uf_is_value   = exprIsHNF        expr,
                    uf_arity      = arity,
                    uf_is_top     = top_lvl,
                    uf_is_value   = exprIsHNF        expr,

@@ -98,7 +168,8 @@ mkUnfolding top_lvl expr
                    uf_guidance   = guidance }
   where
     is_cheap = exprIsCheap expr
                    uf_guidance   = guidance }
   where
     is_cheap = exprIsCheap expr

-    (arity, guidance) = calcUnfoldingGuidance is_cheap opt_UF_CreationThreshold expr
+    (arity, guidance) = calcUnfoldingGuidance is_cheap
+                                              opt_UF_CreationThreshold expr

        -- Sometimes during simplification, there's a large let-bound thing     
        -- which has been substituted, and so is now dead; so 'expr' contains
        -- two copies of the thing while the occurrence-analysed expression doesn't
        -- Sometimes during simplification, there's a large let-bound thing     
        -- which has been substituted, and so is now dead; so 'expr' contains
        -- two copies of the thing while the occurrence-analysed expression doesn't

@@ -108,51 +179,8 @@ mkUnfolding top_lvl expr
        -- This can occasionally mean that the guidance is very pessimistic;
        -- it gets fixed up next round.  And it should be rare, because large
        -- let-bound things that are dead are usually caught by preInlineUnconditionally
        -- This can occasionally mean that the guidance is very pessimistic;
        -- it gets fixed up next round.  And it should be rare, because large
        -- let-bound things that are dead are usually caught by preInlineUnconditionally

-
-mkCoreUnfolding :: Bool -> UnfoldingSource -> CoreExpr
-                -> Arity -> UnfoldingGuidance -> Unfolding
--- Occurrence-analyses the expression before capturing it
-mkCoreUnfolding top_lvl src expr arity guidance 
-  = CoreUnfolding { uf_tmpl      = occurAnalyseExpr expr,
-                   uf_src        = src,
-                   uf_arity      = arity,
-                   uf_is_top     = top_lvl,
-                   uf_is_value   = exprIsHNF        expr,
-                    uf_is_conlike = exprIsConLike    expr,
-                   uf_is_cheap   = exprIsCheap      expr,
-                   uf_expandable = exprIsExpandable expr,
-                   uf_guidance   = guidance }
-
-mkDFunUnfolding :: DataCon -> [Id] -> Unfolding
-mkDFunUnfolding con ops = DFunUnfolding con (map Var ops)
-
-mkWwInlineRule :: Id -> CoreExpr -> Arity -> Unfolding
-mkWwInlineRule id expr arity
-  = mkCoreUnfolding True (InlineWrapper id) 
-                   (simpleOptExpr expr) arity
-                   (UnfWhen unSaturatedOk boringCxtNotOk)
-
-mkCompulsoryUnfolding :: CoreExpr -> Unfolding
-mkCompulsoryUnfolding expr        -- Used for things that absolutely must be unfolded
-  = mkCoreUnfolding True InlineCompulsory
-                    expr 0    -- Arity of unfolding doesn't matter
-                    (UnfWhen unSaturatedOk boringCxtOk)
-
-mkInlineRule :: Bool -> CoreExpr -> Arity -> Unfolding
-mkInlineRule unsat_ok expr arity 
-  = mkCoreUnfolding True InlineRule     -- Note [Top-level flag on inline rules]
-                   expr' arity 
-                   (UnfWhen unsat_ok boring_ok)
-  where
-    expr' = simpleOptExpr expr
-    boring_ok = case calcUnfoldingGuidance True    -- Treat as cheap
-                                           (arity+1) expr' of
-                 (_, UnfWhen _ boring_ok) -> boring_ok
-                 _other                   -> boringCxtNotOk
-     -- See Note [INLINE for small functions]

 \end{code}
 
 \end{code}
 

-

 %************************************************************************
 %*                                                                     *
 \subsection{The UnfoldingGuidance type}
 %************************************************************************
 %*                                                                     *
 \subsection{The UnfoldingGuidance type}

@@ -160,6 +188,28 @@ mkInlineRule unsat_ok expr arity
 %************************************************************************
 
 \begin{code}
 %************************************************************************
 
 \begin{code}

+inlineBoringOk :: CoreExpr -> Bool
+-- See Note [INLINE for small functions]
+-- True => the result of inlining the expression is 
+--         no bigger than the expression itself
+--     eg      (\x y -> f y x)
+-- This is a quick and dirty version. It doesn't attempt
+-- to deal with  (\x y z -> x (y z))
+-- The really important one is (x `cast` c)
+inlineBoringOk e
+  = go 0 e
+  where
+    go :: Int -> CoreExpr -> Bool
+    go credit (Lam x e) | isId x           = go (credit+1) e
+                        | otherwise        = go credit e
+    go credit (App f (Type {}))            = go credit f
+    go credit (App f a) | credit > 0  
+                        , exprIsTrivial a  = go (credit-1) f
+    go credit (Note _ e)                  = go credit e     
+    go credit (Cast e _)                  = go credit e
+    go _      (Var {})                            = boringCxtOk
+    go _      _                                   = boringCxtNotOk
+

 calcUnfoldingGuidance
        :: Bool         -- True <=> the rhs is cheap, or we want to treat it
                        --          as cheap (INLINE things)     
 calcUnfoldingGuidance
        :: Bool         -- True <=> the rhs is cheap, or we want to treat it
                        --          as cheap (INLINE things)     

@@ -176,9 +226,9 @@ calcUnfoldingGuidance expr_is_cheap bOMB_OUT_SIZE expr
           = case (sizeExpr (iUnbox bOMB_OUT_SIZE) val_bndrs body) of
              TooBig -> UnfNever
              SizeIs size cased_bndrs scrut_discount
           = case (sizeExpr (iUnbox bOMB_OUT_SIZE) val_bndrs body) of
              TooBig -> UnfNever
              SizeIs size cased_bndrs scrut_discount

-               | uncondInline n_val_bndrs (iBox size) && expr_is_cheap
-               -> UnfWhen needSaturated boringCxtOk
-
+               | uncondInline n_val_bndrs (iBox size)
+                , expr_is_cheap
+               -> UnfWhen unSaturatedOk boringCxtOk   -- Note [INLINE for small functions]

                | otherwise
                -> UnfIfGoodArgs { ug_args  = map (discount cased_bndrs) val_bndrs
                                 , ug_size  = iBox size
                | otherwise
                -> UnfIfGoodArgs { ug_args  = map (discount cased_bndrs) val_bndrs
                                 , ug_size  = iBox size

@@ -222,24 +272,61 @@ Notice that 'x' counts 0, while (f x) counts 2.  That's deliberate: there's
 a function call to account for.  Notice also that constructor applications 
 are very cheap, because exposing them to a caller is so valuable.
 
 a function call to account for.  Notice also that constructor applications 
 are very cheap, because exposing them to a caller is so valuable.
 

-Note [Unconditional inlining]
-~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~
-We inline *unconditionally* if inlined thing is smaller (using sizeExpr)
-than the thing it's replacing.  Notice that
+
+Note [Do not inline top-level bottoming functions]
+~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~
+The FloatOut pass has gone to some trouble to float out calls to 'error' 
+and similar friends.  See Note [Bottoming floats] in SetLevels.
+Do not re-inline them!  But we *do* still inline if they are very small
+(the uncondInline stuff).
+
+
+Note [INLINE for small functions]
+~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~
+Consider       {-# INLINE f #-}
+                f x = Just x
+                g y = f y
+Then f's RHS is no larger than its LHS, so we should inline it into
+even the most boring context.  In general, f the function is
+sufficiently small that its body is as small as the call itself, the
+inline unconditionally, regardless of how boring the context is.
+
+Things to note:
+
+ * We inline *unconditionally* if inlined thing is smaller (using sizeExpr)
+   than the thing it's replacing.  Notice that

       (f x) --> (g 3)            -- YES, unconditionally
       (f x) --> x : []           -- YES, *even though* there are two
                                  --      arguments to the cons
       x     --> g 3              -- NO
       x            --> Just v            -- NO
 
       (f x) --> (g 3)            -- YES, unconditionally
       (f x) --> x : []           -- YES, *even though* there are two
                                  --      arguments to the cons
       x     --> g 3              -- NO
       x            --> Just v            -- NO
 

-It's very important not to unconditionally replace a variable by
-a non-atomic term.
+  It's very important not to unconditionally replace a variable by
+  a non-atomic term.
+
+* We do this even if the thing isn't saturated, else we end up with the
+  silly situation that
+     f x y = x
+     ...map (f 3)...
+  doesn't inline.  Even in a boring context, inlining without being
+  saturated will give a lambda instead of a PAP, and will be more
+  efficient at runtime.
+
+* However, when the function's arity > 0, we do insist that it 
+  has at least one value argument at the call site.  Otherwise we find this:
+       f = /\a \x:a. x
+       d = /\b. MkD (f b)
+  If we inline f here we get
+       d = /\b. MkD (\x:b. x)
+  and then prepareRhs floats out the argument, abstracting the type
+  variables, so we end up with the original again!
+

 
 \begin{code}
 uncondInline :: Arity -> Int -> Bool
 -- Inline unconditionally if there no size increase
 -- Size of call is arity (+1 for the function)
 
 \begin{code}
 uncondInline :: Arity -> Int -> Bool
 -- Inline unconditionally if there no size increase
 -- Size of call is arity (+1 for the function)

--- See Note [Unconditional inlining]
+-- See Note [INLINE for small functions]

 uncondInline arity size 
   | arity == 0 = size == 0
   | otherwise  = size <= arity + 1
 uncondInline arity size 
   | arity == 0 = size == 0
   | otherwise  = size <= arity + 1

@@ -266,29 +353,27 @@ sizeExpr bOMB_OUT_SIZE top_args expr
                                            -- discounts even on nullary constructors
 
     size_up (App fun (Type _)) = size_up fun
                                            -- discounts even on nullary constructors
 
     size_up (App fun (Type _)) = size_up fun

-    size_up (App fun arg)      = size_up_app fun [arg]
-                                 `addSize` nukeScrutDiscount (size_up arg)
+    size_up (App fun arg)      = size_up arg  `addSizeNSD`
+                                 size_up_app fun [arg]

 
     size_up (Lam b e) | isId b    = lamScrutDiscount (size_up e `addSizeN` 1)
                      | otherwise = size_up e
 
     size_up (Let (NonRec binder rhs) body)
 
     size_up (Lam b e) | isId b    = lamScrutDiscount (size_up e `addSizeN` 1)
                      | otherwise = size_up e
 
     size_up (Let (NonRec binder rhs) body)

-      = nukeScrutDiscount (size_up rhs)                `addSize`
-       size_up body                            `addSizeN`
+      = size_up rhs            `addSizeNSD`
+       size_up body            `addSizeN`

        (if isUnLiftedType (idType binder) then 0 else 1)
                -- For the allocation
                -- If the binder has an unlifted type there is no allocation
 
     size_up (Let (Rec pairs) body)
        (if isUnLiftedType (idType binder) then 0 else 1)
                -- For the allocation
                -- If the binder has an unlifted type there is no allocation
 
     size_up (Let (Rec pairs) body)

-      = nukeScrutDiscount rhs_size             `addSize`
-       size_up body                            `addSizeN`
-       length pairs            -- For the allocation
-      where
-       rhs_size = foldr (addSize . size_up . snd) sizeZero pairs
+      = foldr (addSizeNSD . size_up . snd) 
+              (size_up body `addSizeN` length pairs)   -- (length pairs) for the allocation
+              pairs

 
     size_up (Case (Var v) _ _ alts) 
        | v `elem` top_args             -- We are scrutinising an argument variable
 
     size_up (Case (Var v) _ _ alts) 
        | v `elem` top_args             -- We are scrutinising an argument variable

-       = alts_size (foldr1 addSize alt_sizes)  -- The 1 is for the case itself
+       = alts_size (foldr1 addAltSize alt_sizes)

                    (foldr1 maxSize alt_sizes)
                -- Good to inline if an arg is scrutinised, because
                -- that may eliminate allocation in the caller
                    (foldr1 maxSize alt_sizes)
                -- Good to inline if an arg is scrutinised, because
                -- that may eliminate allocation in the caller

@@ -298,9 +383,9 @@ sizeExpr bOMB_OUT_SIZE top_args expr
 
                -- alts_size tries to compute a good discount for
                -- the case when we are scrutinising an argument variable
 
                -- alts_size tries to compute a good discount for
                -- the case when we are scrutinising an argument variable

-         alts_size (SizeIs tot tot_disc _tot_scrut)           -- Size of all alternatives
-                   (SizeIs max _max_disc  max_scrut)           -- Size of biggest alternative
-               = SizeIs tot (unitBag (v, iBox (_ILIT(2) +# tot -# max)) `unionBags` tot_disc) max_scrut
+         alts_size (SizeIs tot tot_disc tot_scrut)  -- Size of all alternatives
+                   (SizeIs max _        _)          -- Size of biggest alternative
+               = SizeIs tot (unitBag (v, iBox (_ILIT(2) +# tot -# max)) `unionBags` tot_disc) tot_scrut

                        -- If the variable is known, we produce a discount that
                        -- will take us back to 'max', the size of the largest alternative
                        -- The 1+ is a little discount for reduced allocation in the caller
                        -- If the variable is known, we produce a discount that
                        -- will take us back to 'max', the size of the largest alternative
                        -- The 1+ is a little discount for reduced allocation in the caller

@@ -310,9 +395,8 @@ sizeExpr bOMB_OUT_SIZE top_args expr
 
          alts_size tot_size _ = tot_size
 
 
          alts_size tot_size _ = tot_size
 

-    size_up (Case e _ _ alts) = foldr (addSize . size_up_alt) 
-                                     (nukeScrutDiscount (size_up e))
-                                     alts
+    size_up (Case e _ _ alts) = size_up e  `addSizeNSD` 
+                                foldr (addAltSize . size_up_alt) sizeZero alts

                -- We don't charge for the case itself
                -- It's a strict thing, and the price of the call
                -- is paid by scrut.  Also consider
                -- We don't charge for the case itself
                -- It's a strict thing, and the price of the call
                -- is paid by scrut.  Also consider

@@ -325,8 +409,8 @@ sizeExpr bOMB_OUT_SIZE top_args expr
     -- size_up_app is used when there's ONE OR MORE value args
     size_up_app (App fun arg) args 
        | isTypeArg arg            = size_up_app fun args
     -- size_up_app is used when there's ONE OR MORE value args
     size_up_app (App fun arg) args 
        | isTypeArg arg            = size_up_app fun args

-       | otherwise                = size_up_app fun (arg:args)
-                                    `addSize` nukeScrutDiscount (size_up arg)
+       | otherwise                = size_up arg  `addSizeNSD`
+                                     size_up_app fun (arg:args)

     size_up_app (Var fun)     args = size_up_call fun args
     size_up_app other         args = size_up other `addSizeN` length args
 
     size_up_app (Var fun)     args = size_up_call fun args
     size_up_app other         args = size_up other `addSizeN` length args
 

@@ -355,10 +439,22 @@ sizeExpr bOMB_OUT_SIZE top_args expr
     addSizeN TooBig          _  = TooBig
     addSizeN (SizeIs n xs d) m         = mkSizeIs bOMB_OUT_SIZE (n +# iUnbox m) xs d
     
     addSizeN TooBig          _  = TooBig
     addSizeN (SizeIs n xs d) m         = mkSizeIs bOMB_OUT_SIZE (n +# iUnbox m) xs d
     

-    addSize TooBig           _                 = TooBig
-    addSize _                TooBig            = TooBig
-    addSize (SizeIs n1 xs d1) (SizeIs n2 ys d2) 
-       = mkSizeIs bOMB_OUT_SIZE (n1 +# n2) (xs `unionBags` ys) (d1 +# d2)
+        -- addAltSize is used to add the sizes of case alternatives
+    addAltSize TooBig           _      = TooBig
+    addAltSize _                TooBig = TooBig
+    addAltSize (SizeIs n1 xs d1) (SizeIs n2 ys d2) 
+       = mkSizeIs bOMB_OUT_SIZE (n1 +# n2) 
+                                 (xs `unionBags` ys) 
+                                 (d1 +# d2)   -- Note [addAltSize result discounts]
+
+        -- This variant ignores the result discount from its LEFT argument
+       -- It's used when the second argument isn't part of the result
+    addSizeNSD TooBig           _      = TooBig
+    addSizeNSD _                TooBig = TooBig
+    addSizeNSD (SizeIs n1 xs _) (SizeIs n2 ys d2) 
+       = mkSizeIs bOMB_OUT_SIZE (n1 +# n2) 
+                                 (xs `unionBags` ys) 
+                                 d2  -- Ignore d1

 \end{code}
 
 \begin{code}
 \end{code}
 
 \begin{code}

@@ -418,21 +514,44 @@ funSize top_args fun n_val_args
 
 conSize :: DataCon -> Int -> ExprSize
 conSize dc n_val_args
 
 conSize :: DataCon -> Int -> ExprSize
 conSize dc n_val_args

-  | n_val_args == 0      = SizeIs (_ILIT(0)) emptyBag (_ILIT(1))       -- Like variables
+  | n_val_args == 0 = SizeIs (_ILIT(0)) emptyBag (_ILIT(1))    -- Like variables
+
+-- See Note [Constructor size]

   | isUnboxedTupleCon dc = SizeIs (_ILIT(0)) emptyBag (iUnbox n_val_args +# _ILIT(1))
   | isUnboxedTupleCon dc = SizeIs (_ILIT(0)) emptyBag (iUnbox n_val_args +# _ILIT(1))

-  | otherwise           = SizeIs (_ILIT(1)) emptyBag (iUnbox n_val_args +# _ILIT(1))
-       -- Treat a constructors application as size 1, regardless of how
-       -- many arguments it has; we are keen to expose them
-       -- (and we charge separately for their args).  We can't treat
-       -- them as size zero, else we find that (Just x) has size 0,
-       -- which is the same as a lone variable; and hence 'v' will 
-       -- always be replaced by (Just x), where v is bound to Just x.
-       --
-       -- However, unboxed tuples count as size zero
-       -- I found occasions where we had 
-       --      f x y z = case op# x y z of { s -> (# s, () #) }
-       -- and f wasn't getting inlined

 
 

+-- See Note [Unboxed tuple result discount]
+--  | isUnboxedTupleCon dc = SizeIs (_ILIT(0)) emptyBag (_ILIT(0))
+
+-- See Note [Constructor size]
+  | otherwise = SizeIs (_ILIT(1)) emptyBag (iUnbox n_val_args +# _ILIT(1))
+\end{code}
+
+Note [Constructor size]
+~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~
+Treat a constructors application as size 1, regardless of how many
+arguments it has; we are keen to expose them (and we charge separately
+for their args).  We can't treat them as size zero, else we find that
+(Just x) has size 0, which is the same as a lone variable; and hence
+'v' will always be replaced by (Just x), where v is bound to Just x.
+
+However, unboxed tuples count as size zero. I found occasions where we had 
+       f x y z = case op# x y z of { s -> (# s, () #) }
+and f wasn't getting inlined.
+
+Note [Unboxed tuple result discount]
+~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~
+I tried giving unboxed tuples a *result discount* of zero (see the
+commented-out line).  Why?  When returned as a result they do not
+allocate, so maybe we don't want to charge so much for them If you
+have a non-zero discount here, we find that workers often get inlined
+back into wrappers, because it look like
+    f x = case $wf x of (# a,b #) -> (a,b)
+and we are keener because of the case.  However while this change
+shrank binary sizes by 0.5% it also made spectral/boyer allocate 5%
+more. All other changes were very small. So it's not a big deal but I
+didn't adopt the idea.
+
+\begin{code}

 primOpSize :: PrimOp -> Int -> ExprSize
 primOpSize op n_val_args
  | not (primOpIsDupable op) = sizeN opt_UF_DearOp
 primOpSize :: PrimOp -> Int -> ExprSize
 primOpSize op n_val_args
  | not (primOpIsDupable op) = sizeN opt_UF_DearOp

@@ -464,16 +583,21 @@ augmentSize = SizeIs (_ILIT(0)) emptyBag (_ILIT(4))
        -- Ditto (augment t (\cn -> e) ys) should cost only the cost of
        -- e plus ys. The -2 accounts for the \cn 
 
        -- Ditto (augment t (\cn -> e) ys) should cost only the cost of
        -- e plus ys. The -2 accounts for the \cn 
 

-nukeScrutDiscount :: ExprSize -> ExprSize
-nukeScrutDiscount (SizeIs n vs _) = SizeIs n vs (_ILIT(0))
-nukeScrutDiscount TooBig          = TooBig
-

 -- When we return a lambda, give a discount if it's used (applied)
 lamScrutDiscount :: ExprSize -> ExprSize
 lamScrutDiscount (SizeIs n vs _) = SizeIs n vs (iUnbox opt_UF_FunAppDiscount)
 lamScrutDiscount TooBig          = TooBig
 \end{code}
 
 -- When we return a lambda, give a discount if it's used (applied)
 lamScrutDiscount :: ExprSize -> ExprSize
 lamScrutDiscount (SizeIs n vs _) = SizeIs n vs (iUnbox opt_UF_FunAppDiscount)
 lamScrutDiscount TooBig          = TooBig
 \end{code}
 

+Note [addAltSize result discounts]
+~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~
+When adding the size of alternatives, we *add* the result discounts
+too, rather than take the *maximum*.  For a multi-branch case, this
+gives a discount for each branch that returns a constructor, making us
+keener to inline.  I did try using 'max' instead, but it makes nofib 
+'rewrite' and 'puzzle' allocate significantly more, and didn't make
+binary sizes shrink significantly either.
+

 Note [Discounts and thresholds]
 ~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~
 Constants for discounts and thesholds are defined in main/StaticFlags,
 Note [Discounts and thresholds]
 ~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~
 Constants for discounts and thesholds are defined in main/StaticFlags,

@@ -566,9 +690,11 @@ actual arguments.
 \begin{code}
 couldBeSmallEnoughToInline :: Int -> CoreExpr -> Bool
 couldBeSmallEnoughToInline threshold rhs 
 \begin{code}
 couldBeSmallEnoughToInline :: Int -> CoreExpr -> Bool
 couldBeSmallEnoughToInline threshold rhs 

-  = case calcUnfoldingGuidance False threshold rhs of
-       (_, UnfNever) -> False
-       _             -> True
+  = case sizeExpr (iUnbox threshold) [] body of
+       TooBig -> False
+       _      -> True
+  where
+    (_, body) = collectBinders rhs

 
 ----------------
 smallEnoughToInline :: Unfolding -> Bool
 
 ----------------
 smallEnoughToInline :: Unfolding -> Bool

@@ -616,13 +742,12 @@ StrictAnal.addStrictnessInfoToTopId
 \begin{code}
 callSiteInline :: DynFlags
               -> Id                    -- The Id
 \begin{code}
 callSiteInline :: DynFlags
               -> Id                    -- The Id

-              -> Unfolding             -- Its unfolding (if active)
+              -> Bool                  -- True <=> unfolding is active

               -> Bool                  -- True if there are are no arguments at all (incl type args)
               -> [ArgSummary]          -- One for each value arg; True if it is interesting
               -> CallCtxt              -- True <=> continuation is interesting
               -> Maybe CoreExpr        -- Unfolding, if any
 
               -> Bool                  -- True if there are are no arguments at all (incl type args)
               -> [ArgSummary]          -- One for each value arg; True if it is interesting
               -> CallCtxt              -- True <=> continuation is interesting
               -> Maybe CoreExpr        -- Unfolding, if any
 

-

 instance Outputable ArgSummary where
   ppr TrivArg    = ptext (sLit "TrivArg")
   ppr NonTrivArg = ptext (sLit "NonTrivArg")
 instance Outputable ArgSummary where
   ppr TrivArg    = ptext (sLit "TrivArg")
   ppr NonTrivArg = ptext (sLit "NonTrivArg")

@@ -651,80 +776,91 @@ instance Outputable CallCtxt where
   ppr CaseCtxt               = ptext (sLit "CaseCtxt")
   ppr ValAppCtxt      = ptext (sLit "ValAppCtxt")
 
   ppr CaseCtxt               = ptext (sLit "CaseCtxt")
   ppr ValAppCtxt      = ptext (sLit "ValAppCtxt")
 

-callSiteInline dflags id unfolding lone_variable arg_infos cont_info
-  = case unfolding of {
-       NoUnfolding      -> Nothing ;
-       OtherCon _       -> Nothing ;
-       DFunUnfolding {} -> Nothing ;   -- Never unfold a DFun
-       CoreUnfolding { uf_tmpl = unf_template, uf_is_top = is_top, uf_is_value = is_value,
-                       uf_is_cheap = is_cheap, uf_arity = uf_arity, uf_guidance = guidance } ->
+callSiteInline dflags id active_unfolding lone_variable arg_infos cont_info
+  = case idUnfolding id of 
+      -- idUnfolding checks for loop-breakers, returning NoUnfolding
+      -- Things with an INLINE pragma may have an unfolding *and* 
+      -- be a loop breaker  (maybe the knot is not yet untied)
+       CoreUnfolding { uf_tmpl = unf_template, uf_is_top = is_top 
+                     , uf_is_cheap = is_cheap, uf_arity = uf_arity
+                      , uf_guidance = guidance }
+          | active_unfolding -> tryUnfolding dflags id lone_variable 
+                                    arg_infos cont_info unf_template is_top 
+                                    is_cheap uf_arity guidance
+          | otherwise    -> Nothing
+       NoUnfolding      -> Nothing 
+       OtherCon {}      -> Nothing 
+       DFunUnfolding {} -> Nothing     -- Never unfold a DFun
+
+tryUnfolding :: DynFlags -> Id -> Bool -> [ArgSummary] -> CallCtxt
+             -> CoreExpr -> Bool -> Bool -> Arity -> UnfoldingGuidance
+            -> Maybe CoreExpr  
+tryUnfolding dflags id lone_variable 
+             arg_infos cont_info unf_template is_top 
+             is_cheap uf_arity guidance

                        -- uf_arity will typically be equal to (idArity id), 
                        -- but may be less for InlineRules
                        -- uf_arity will typically be equal to (idArity id), 
                        -- but may be less for InlineRules

-    let
-       n_val_args = length arg_infos
-        saturated  = n_val_args >= uf_arity
-
-       result | yes_or_no = Just unf_template
-              | otherwise = Nothing
-
-       interesting_args = any nonTriv arg_infos 
-               -- NB: (any nonTriv arg_infos) looks at the
-               -- over-saturated args too which is "wrong"; 
-               -- but if over-saturated we inline anyway.
-
-              -- some_benefit is used when the RHS is small enough
-              -- and the call has enough (or too many) value
-              -- arguments (ie n_val_args >= arity). But there must
-              -- be *something* interesting about some argument, or the
-              -- result context, to make it worth inlining
-       some_benefit 
-           | not saturated = interesting_args  -- Under-saturated
-                                               -- Note [Unsaturated applications]
-          | n_val_args > uf_arity = True       -- Over-saturated
-           | otherwise = interesting_args      -- Saturated
-                      || interesting_saturated_call 
-
-       interesting_saturated_call 
-         = case cont_info of
-             BoringCtxt -> not is_top && uf_arity > 0          -- Note [Nested functions]
-             CaseCtxt   -> not (lone_variable && is_value)     -- Note [Lone variables]
-             ArgCtxt {} -> uf_arity > 0                        -- Note [Inlining in ArgCtxt]
-             ValAppCtxt -> True                                -- Note [Cast then apply]
-
-       (yes_or_no, extra_doc)
-         = case guidance of
-             UnfNever -> (False, empty)
-
-             UnfWhen unsat_ok boring_ok -> ( (unsat_ok  || saturated)
-                                           && (boring_ok || some_benefit)
-                                            , empty )
-                  -- For the boring_ok part see Note [INLINE for small functions]
-
-             UnfIfGoodArgs { ug_args = arg_discounts, ug_res = res_discount, ug_size = size }
-                -> ( is_cheap && some_benefit && small_enough
-                    , (text "discounted size =" <+> int discounted_size) )
-                where
-                  discounted_size = size - discount
-                  small_enough = discounted_size <= opt_UF_UseThreshold
-                  discount = computeDiscount uf_arity arg_discounts 
-                                             res_discount arg_infos cont_info
-               
-    in    
-    if dopt Opt_D_dump_inlinings dflags then
-       pprTrace ("Considering inlining: " ++ showSDoc (ppr id))
+ | dopt Opt_D_dump_inlinings dflags && dopt Opt_D_verbose_core2core dflags
+ = pprTrace ("Considering inlining: " ++ showSDoc (ppr id))

                 (vcat [text "arg infos" <+> ppr arg_infos,
                        text "uf arity" <+> ppr uf_arity,
                        text "interesting continuation" <+> ppr cont_info,
                        text "some_benefit" <+> ppr some_benefit,
                 (vcat [text "arg infos" <+> ppr arg_infos,
                        text "uf arity" <+> ppr uf_arity,
                        text "interesting continuation" <+> ppr cont_info,
                        text "some_benefit" <+> ppr some_benefit,

-                       text "is value:" <+> ppr is_value,

                         text "is cheap:" <+> ppr is_cheap,
                        text "guidance" <+> ppr guidance,
                        extra_doc,
                        text "ANSWER =" <+> if yes_or_no then text "YES" else text "NO"])
                         text "is cheap:" <+> ppr is_cheap,
                        text "guidance" <+> ppr guidance,
                        extra_doc,
                        text "ANSWER =" <+> if yes_or_no then text "YES" else text "NO"])

-                 result
-    else
-    result
-    }
+                result
+  | otherwise  = result
+
+  where
+    n_val_args = length arg_infos
+    saturated  = n_val_args >= uf_arity
+
+    result | yes_or_no = Just unf_template
+           | otherwise = Nothing
+
+    interesting_args = any nonTriv arg_infos 
+       -- NB: (any nonTriv arg_infos) looks at the
+       -- over-saturated args too which is "wrong"; 
+       -- but if over-saturated we inline anyway.
+
+           -- some_benefit is used when the RHS is small enough
+           -- and the call has enough (or too many) value
+           -- arguments (ie n_val_args >= arity). But there must
+           -- be *something* interesting about some argument, or the
+           -- result context, to make it worth inlining
+    some_benefit 
+       | not saturated = interesting_args      -- Under-saturated
+                                       -- Note [Unsaturated applications]
+       | n_val_args > uf_arity = True  -- Over-saturated
+       | otherwise = interesting_args  -- Saturated
+                  || interesting_saturated_call 
+
+    interesting_saturated_call 
+      = case cont_info of
+          BoringCtxt -> not is_top && uf_arity > 0           -- Note [Nested functions]
+          CaseCtxt   -> not (lone_variable && is_cheap)   -- Note [Lone variables]
+          ArgCtxt {} -> uf_arity > 0                         -- Note [Inlining in ArgCtxt]
+          ValAppCtxt -> True                         -- Note [Cast then apply]
+
+    (yes_or_no, extra_doc)
+      = case guidance of
+          UnfNever -> (False, empty)
+
+          UnfWhen unsat_ok boring_ok 
+             -> (enough_args && (boring_ok || some_benefit), empty )
+             where      -- See Note [INLINE for small functions]
+               enough_args = saturated || (unsat_ok && n_val_args > 0)
+
+          UnfIfGoodArgs { ug_args = arg_discounts, ug_res = res_discount, ug_size = size }
+            -> ( is_cheap && some_benefit && small_enough
+                , (text "discounted size =" <+> int discounted_size) )
+            where
+              discounted_size = size - discount
+              small_enough = discounted_size <= opt_UF_UseThreshold
+              discount = computeDiscount uf_arity arg_discounts 
+                                         res_discount arg_infos cont_info

 \end{code}
 
 Note [RHS of lets]
 \end{code}
 
 Note [RHS of lets]

@@ -758,22 +894,12 @@ But the defn of GHC.Classes.$dmmin is:
     {- Arity: 3, HasNoCafRefs, Strictness: SLL,
        Unfolding: (\ @ a $dOrd :: GHC.Classes.Ord a x :: a y :: a ->
                    case @ a GHC.Classes.<= @ a $dOrd x y of wild {
     {- Arity: 3, HasNoCafRefs, Strictness: SLL,
        Unfolding: (\ @ a $dOrd :: GHC.Classes.Ord a x :: a y :: a ->
                    case @ a GHC.Classes.<= @ a $dOrd x y of wild {

-                     GHC.Bool.False -> y GHC.Bool.True -> x }) -}
+                     GHC.Types.False -> y GHC.Types.True -> x }) -}

 
 We *really* want to inline $dmmin, even though it has arity 3, in
 order to unravel the recursion.
 
 
 
 We *really* want to inline $dmmin, even though it has arity 3, in
 order to unravel the recursion.
 
 

-Note [INLINE for small functions]
-~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~
-Consider       {-# INLINE f #-}
-                f x = Just x
-                g y = f y
-Then f's RHS is no larger than its LHS, so we should inline it
-into even the most boring context.  (We do so if there is no INLINE
-pragma!)  
-
-

 Note [Things to watch]
 ~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~
 *   { y = I# 3; x = y `cast` co; ...case (x `cast` co) of ... }
 Note [Things to watch]
 ~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~
 *   { y = I# 3; x = y `cast` co; ...case (x `cast` co) of ... }

@@ -840,8 +966,8 @@ call is at least CONLIKE.  At least for the cases where we use ArgCtxt
 for the RHS of a 'let', we only profit from the inlining if we get a 
 CONLIKE thing (modulo lets).
 
 for the RHS of a 'let', we only profit from the inlining if we get a 
 CONLIKE thing (modulo lets).
 

-Note [Lone variables]
-~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~
+Note [Lone variables]  See also Note [Interaction of exprIsCheap and lone variables]
+~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~   which appears below

 The "lone-variable" case is important.  I spent ages messing about
 with unsatisfactory varaints, but this is nice.  The idea is that if a
 variable appears all alone
 The "lone-variable" case is important.  I spent ages messing about
 with unsatisfactory varaints, but this is nice.  The idea is that if a
 variable appears all alone

@@ -850,7 +976,7 @@ variable appears all alone
        as scrutinee of a case          CaseCtxt
        as arg of a fn                  ArgCtxt
 AND
        as scrutinee of a case          CaseCtxt
        as arg of a fn                  ArgCtxt
 AND

-       it is bound to a value
+       it is bound to a cheap expression

 
 then we should not inline it (unless there is some other reason,
 e.g. is is the sole occurrence).  That is what is happening at 
 
 then we should not inline it (unless there is some other reason,
 e.g. is is the sole occurrence).  That is what is happening at 

@@ -902,6 +1028,27 @@ However, watch out:
    There's no advantage in inlining f here, and perhaps
    a significant disadvantage.  Hence some_val_args in the Stop case
 
    There's no advantage in inlining f here, and perhaps
    a significant disadvantage.  Hence some_val_args in the Stop case
 

+Note [Interaction of exprIsCheap and lone variables]
+~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~
+The lone-variable test says "don't inline if a case expression
+scrutines a lone variable whose unfolding is cheap".  It's very 
+important that, under these circumstances, exprIsConApp_maybe
+can spot a constructor application. So, for example, we don't
+consider
+       let x = e in (x,x)
+to be cheap, and that's good because exprIsConApp_maybe doesn't
+think that expression is a constructor application.
+
+I used to test is_value rather than is_cheap, which was utterly
+wrong, because the above expression responds True to exprIsHNF.
+
+This kind of thing can occur if you have
+
+       {-# INLINE foo #-}
+       foo = let x = e in (x,x)
+
+which Roman did.
+

 \begin{code}
 computeDiscount :: Int -> [Int] -> Int -> [ArgSummary] -> CallCtxt -> Int
 computeDiscount n_vals_wanted arg_discounts res_discount arg_infos cont_info
 \begin{code}
 computeDiscount :: Int -> [Int] -> Int -> [ArgSummary] -> CallCtxt -> Int
 computeDiscount n_vals_wanted arg_discounts res_discount arg_infos cont_info

@@ -1004,7 +1151,7 @@ interestingArg e = go e 0
     go (Note _ a)       n = go a n
     go (Cast e _)       n = go e n
     go (Lam v e)        n 
     go (Note _ a)       n = go a n
     go (Cast e _)       n = go e n
     go (Lam v e)        n 

-       | isTyVar v        = go e n
+       | isTyCoVar v      = go e n

        | n>0              = go e (n-1)
        | otherwise        = ValueArg
     go (Let _ e)        n = case go e n of { ValueArg -> ValueArg; _ -> NonTrivArg }
        | n>0              = go e (n-1)
        | otherwise        = ValueArg
     go (Let _ e)        n = case go e n of { ValueArg -> ValueArg; _ -> NonTrivArg }

@@ -1039,13 +1186,14 @@ However e might not *look* as if
 -- where t1..tk are the *universally-qantified* type args of 'dc'
 exprIsConApp_maybe :: IdUnfoldingFun -> CoreExpr -> Maybe (DataCon, [Type], [CoreExpr])
 
 -- where t1..tk are the *universally-qantified* type args of 'dc'
 exprIsConApp_maybe :: IdUnfoldingFun -> CoreExpr -> Maybe (DataCon, [Type], [CoreExpr])
 

-exprIsConApp_maybe id_unf (Note _ expr)
+exprIsConApp_maybe id_unf (Note note expr)
+  | notSccNote note

   = exprIsConApp_maybe id_unf expr
   = exprIsConApp_maybe id_unf expr

-       -- We ignore all notes.  For example,
+       -- We ignore all notes except SCCs.  For example,

        --      case _scc_ "foo" (C a b) of
        --                      C a b -> e
        --      case _scc_ "foo" (C a b) of
        --                      C a b -> e

-       -- should be optimised away, but it will be only if we look
-       -- through the SCC note.
+       -- should not be optimised away, because we'll lose the
+       -- entry count on 'foo'; see Trac #4414

 
 exprIsConApp_maybe id_unf (Cast expr co)
   =     -- Here we do the KPush reduction rule as described in the FC paper
 
 exprIsConApp_maybe id_unf (Cast expr co)
   =     -- Here we do the KPush reduction rule as described in the FC paper

@@ -1124,35 +1272,33 @@ exprIsConApp_maybe id_unf expr
 
     analyse (Var fun) args
        | Just con <- isDataConWorkId_maybe fun
 
     analyse (Var fun) args
        | Just con <- isDataConWorkId_maybe fun

-        , is_saturated
+        , count isValArg args == idArity fun

        , let (univ_ty_args, rest_args) = splitAtList (dataConUnivTyVars con) args
        = Just (con, stripTypeArgs univ_ty_args, rest_args)
 
        -- Look through dictionary functions; see Note [Unfolding DFuns]
        , let (univ_ty_args, rest_args) = splitAtList (dataConUnivTyVars con) args
        = Just (con, stripTypeArgs univ_ty_args, rest_args)
 
        -- Look through dictionary functions; see Note [Unfolding DFuns]

-        | DFunUnfolding con ops <- unfolding
-        , is_saturated
-        , let (dfun_tvs, _cls, dfun_res_tys) = tcSplitDFunTy (idType fun)
-             subst = zipOpenTvSubst dfun_tvs (stripTypeArgs (takeList dfun_tvs args))
-        = Just (con, substTys subst dfun_res_tys, 
-                     [mkApps op args | op <- ops])
+        | DFunUnfolding dfun_nargs con ops <- unfolding
+        , let sat = length args == dfun_nargs    -- See Note [DFun arity check]
+          in if sat then True else 
+             pprTrace "Unsaturated dfun" (ppr fun <+> int dfun_nargs $$ ppr args) False   
+        , let (dfun_tvs, _n_theta, _cls, dfun_res_tys) = tcSplitDFunTy (idType fun)
+              subst    = zipOpenTvSubst dfun_tvs (stripTypeArgs (takeList dfun_tvs args))
+              mk_arg (DFunConstArg e) = e
+              mk_arg (DFunLamArg i)   = args !! i
+              mk_arg (DFunPolyArg e)  = mkApps e args
+        = Just (con, substTys subst dfun_res_tys, map mk_arg ops)

 
        -- Look through unfoldings, but only cheap ones, because
        -- we are effectively duplicating the unfolding
 
        -- Look through unfoldings, but only cheap ones, because
        -- we are effectively duplicating the unfolding

-       | CoreUnfolding { uf_expandable = expand_me, uf_tmpl = rhs } <- unfolding
-       , expand_me = -- pprTrace "expanding" (ppr fun $$ ppr rhs) $
-                      analyse rhs args
+       | Just rhs <- expandUnfolding_maybe unfolding
+       = -- pprTrace "expanding" (ppr fun $$ ppr rhs) $
+          analyse rhs args

         where
         where

-         is_saturated = count isValArg args == idArity fun
-          unfolding = id_unf fun    -- Does not look through loop breakers
-                   -- ToDo: we *may* look through variables that are NOINLINE
-                   --       in this phase, and that is really not right
+         unfolding = id_unf fun

 
     analyse _ _ = Nothing
 
     -----------
 
     analyse _ _ = Nothing
 
     -----------

-    in_scope = mkInScopeSet (exprFreeVars expr)
-
-    -----------

     beta (Lam v body) pairs (arg : args) 
         | isTypeArg arg
         = beta body ((v,arg):pairs) args 
     beta (Lam v body) pairs (arg : args) 
         | isTypeArg arg
         = beta body ((v,arg):pairs) args 

@@ -1161,13 +1307,9 @@ exprIsConApp_maybe id_unf expr
        = Nothing
 
     beta fun pairs args
        = Nothing
 
     beta fun pairs args

-        = case analyse (substExpr subst fun) args of
-           Nothing  -> -- pprTrace "Bale out! exprIsConApp_maybe" doc $
-                       Nothing
-           Just ans -> -- pprTrace "Woo-hoo! exprIsConApp_maybe" doc $
-                        Just ans
+        = analyse (substExpr (text "subst-expr-is-con-app") subst fun) args

         where
         where

-          subst = mkOpenSubst in_scope pairs
+          subst = mkOpenSubst (mkInScopeSet (exprFreeVars fun)) pairs

          -- doc = vcat [ppr fun, ppr expr, ppr pairs, ppr args]
 
 
          -- doc = vcat [ppr fun, ppr expr, ppr pairs, ppr args]
 
 

@@ -1188,3 +1330,8 @@ So to split it up we just need to apply the ops $c1, $c2 etc
 to the very same args as the dfun.  It takes a little more work
 to compute the type arguments to the dictionary constructor.
 
 to the very same args as the dfun.  It takes a little more work
 to compute the type arguments to the dictionary constructor.
 

+Note [DFun arity check]
+~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~
+Here we check that the total number of supplied arguments (inclding 
+type args) matches what the dfun is expecting.  This may be *less*
+than the ordinary arity of the dfun: see Note [DFun unfoldings] in CoreSyn